Hand-held, portable, and packed with delicious fillings, hand pies are one of our favorite classic comfort foods. Intensely rich and unforgettably delicious, it’s a celebration food that every New Englander should make at least once. I grew up in New England, with many summer weeks spent enjoying lobster rolls with my family in Maine. Used a standard rectangular glass casserole dish 9×11 and doubled the topping mix. Add butter, garlic, and olive oil to a large microwave safe bowl and cook for 2 minutes until garlic softens. live lobsters. Add brandy and stir for 1 to 2 minutes. https://www.allroadsleadtothe.kitchen/2016/02/easy-lobster-pie-recipe.html I have made it with shrimp and scallops and it was delicious! The key is to use the freshest lobster and seafood you can find. Ready In: 30 min. Hands-On Time: 25 minutes When the water comes to a second boil, cook the lobsters for 12 to 15 minutes. I added all the seasonings, veggies and wine to make it even more succulent and completely decadent! m-m-m-m-m-, this sounds wonderful. We were disappointed. Step 3 … For lobster and scallop fisherman's pie: 1. Saved from gardenandtable.net. From City Tavern: Recipes from the Birthplace of American Cuisine, ©2009 by Walter Staib. smcl — May 13, 2020 @ 6:15 pm Reply. Best of New England Seafood Recipes: How to Cook Scallops, How to Make Clam Chowder, Cooking Lobster Tails, Cod Fillet Recipes, Haddock Recipes and More. 4. Make the filling: Melt butter in a large pot over medium heat. What do you mean by “3 tablespoons plus 5 tablespoons salted butter ” as stated in “ingredients”. I’d love to know the answer if you ever got a response. The best lobster pie I have ever had was at the Stockyard restaurant in Boston (Brighton). Live in Boston all of my life until I retired to Florida 22 year ago. By. Remove the lobsters from the water and let cool. Lobster Pot Pie. Total Time: 40 minutes I will not make it again, nor will I recommend this recipe. For … Purchase four to six 1 1/4 lb. Bring the catch of the day home with Red Lobster favorites like buttery shrimp scampi, lobster tails, stuffed flounder and—of course—those addictive, cheesy little biscuits. Live lobsters, lobster tails and frozen meat packs. Using a hand mixer, mash the potatoes first. Half and half is one product that is half whole milk, half heavy cream. 1/2 recipe basic savory crust (recipe included), rolled out to the size of the pan. Best Apple Recipes: Easy Desserts with Apples, Best Apples for Apple Pie, Our Favorite Apple Turnover Recipe, and More! Ingredients for Lobster Bisque: 1 pound raw lobster tail 1/3 cup butter 1 medium onion, chopped 2 shallots, finely chopped Amesbury, Massachusetts 01913 Lobster shells are stuffed with cooked lobster in a creamy white wine sauce, then topped with Parmesan cheese and broiled until golden. Can anyone suggest alternatives? Put lobsters in boiling water. You could probably use dry Marsala in place of the sherry! Stir in stock, and bring to a boil. They didn’t. Add butter and heavy cream. Thank you. I just made this recipe and like the previous comments, it had very little flavor. But I realize lobster is best!! Pick out the meat from the shells over a bowl to hold the juices. Preheat oven to 375 degrees. . Place a rack in top-most position of oven; preheat to 400°. Can I use cream sherry instead of dry sherry. Place lobster in a casserole dish and top with cracker mixture. Lobster in Florida not so good. Amazing, I was at the Stockyard grand opening. Just prepared this recipe and enjoyed it immensely! It had a bread crumb topping and the filling was chunks of delicious lobster in a lemon/butter/garlic sauce. I called them recently to see if they still had this dish on their menu. Crack the tails, knuckles and claws. It means that you will need 8 Tbsp total, but not all at the same time. I live in the Midwest and fresh lobster meat isn’t really an option. I made this for the first time a couple of months ago and had leftovers. Divide lobster mixture between four 8-oz. Throw lobster and bacon into the mix and you are basically in foodie heaven… no, seriously. BASIC SAVORY PIE CRUST: 3 1/4 cups flour. Add some extra crab meat, shrimp, and fish fillets for a seafood chowder that carries even more … Drizzle remaining butter on top and bake at 350º F for 20-25 minutes. It just so happens that it is British Pie week and I am once again teaming up with Iceland’s Power Of Frozen campaign to lift the lid on pies – I used their Canadian lobster tails and frozen puff pastry in this recipe. Blend this mixture well with the crackers. Take the rest of the butter and put in a skillet, squeeze the juice from the lemon in, add fresh dill (about 1/2 cup). Linda M, That was sure a lot of typing for such an easy recipe, but it is worth it. Remove tail and claws from each lobster. Give the Authentic Maine experience to family, friends or special clients. Lobster Pot Pies Lobster Recipes Seafood Recipes Appetizer Recipes Seafood Pie Recipe Lobster Quiche Recipe Dinner Recipes Lobster Dip Lobster Bisque Recipe. You will need three Tbsp for one part of the recipe, then five Tbsp for a different part. cocottes or ramekins set on a rimmed baking sheet. Sauté onions, celery, and carrots for 6 to 7 minutes or until tender. Sherry is inexpensive and a wonderful flavor enhancer for a lot of savory dishes, well worth the investment. Call us at 978.225.8828. When I lived in Boston 20 years ago, I used to go to Jimmy Magg’s “Napoles” Restaurante Bar and Lounge. Season with salt and pepper. I thought with 1/2 cup of sherry, I would taste it. Nothing could be simpler, and nothing could taste better. This recipe sounds good, but don’t remember eggs, cream and cheese in that pie. Add Maine seafood company. I’m so excited to share this second recipe with you from our Feast of the Seven Fishes cocktail party series—Mini Lobster Pot Pies! https://www.foodrepublic.com/recipes/lobster-pot-pie-recipe Heat oven to 425°. This recipe is an old New England lobsterman's staple. I make this recipe every single year as part of our Christmas eve feast of 7 fishes and I always make it a day or two in advance and then bake it off when we get ready to eat…its better than same day as the flavors ” ripen” or meld…try it you wont be dissapointed. Stir in mushrooms and garlic, and cook 5 more minutes, stirring occasionally. Lobster Pasta Recipe - Food.com Posted: (2 days ago) Separate the lobster tail and cut in half lengthwise, then into slices crosswise. Yield: 4 to 6 servings. Add flour and stir until combined, cooking 1 to 2 minutes. Learn how to cook great Chicken and lobster pot pie . Chunks of rich lobster meat, plenty of vegetables, and a creamy corn base make this chowder an excellent main-dish option with a side of crusty bread for dipping. Salt the water and add the lobsters. Lobster Pie recipe. Feast of the Seven Fishes: Mini Lobster Pot Pie. If that is not available in Scotland, you could substitute 3/4 cup of each. For the pie filling: 250g spinach; 750g mashed potato; 100g mature cheddar or Gruyere, finely grated; 400g raw tiger prawns; 5 lobster tails, around 750g, thickly sliced; 20g breadcrumbs; You wll need: 1.7 litre dish; Method. If you have no access to live lobster, you can use high quality frozen lobster meat. 2. Preparation. Stir in lobster and dill, and divide among four 10-ounce baking dishes. Thanks! You might try frozen Maine lobster. NO…its a vital ingredient and it must be dry sherry , not CREAM sherry which is a dessert wine. Don’t worry, they won’t bite! Article by SAVEUR. Hubby and I are also native New Englanders who now call Florida home (going on 30 years! Place lobster in a casserole dish and top with cracker mixture. I put the rest together and baked it for 15 minutes. This is the restaurant with an airplane in the rooftop – hard to miss! Bring a large pot of water to a boil over high heat. Set aside. I’m not sure where the liquid is supposed to come from. Just canned lobster meat, crumbs either with it without and butter in the side. At the time, my husband and I decided that the leftovers were even better than the first meal. Absolutely amazing! 12 Oakland St. The best lobster pie starts with fresh lobster meat. Dessert. We suggest par cooked lobster meat so your lobster pie meat bakes up tender, not tough. This is an exceptionally good recipe! Agree with Tammy it just needs more topping, or crust. Your email address will not be published. Lobster Shepherd's Pies - (Free Recipe below) Description Lobster Shepherd's Pies Individual shepherd's pies can be baked in fluted ramekins, shallow ovenproof casseroles, or even Pyrex bowls. Take a break and read about all of your favorite locations that made the Best of New England Hall of Fame. Stir in flour, and cook for 1 minute. I used 1 cup of fat free half and half and 1/2 cup of buttermilk (because I had some) and cut out a bit of the butter. Afterwards I thought the filling was so close to Hollandaise, it might as well include some lemon juice? 3. Set back in the oven for about 5 minutes. Stir in lobster tails and boil until they turn bright red and the meat becomes opaque, 5 to 8 minutes. I live in south Louisiana I can try .w/ crayfish! Makes 4 servings, 190 calories per serving Ingredients: butter, sherry, lobsters, milk, flour, butter, egg yolks Divide lobster mixture between four 8-oz. Put the lobster in a bowl and drizzle with melted butter (1/2 stick melted). 2.2k. Get one of our Chicken and lobster pot pie recipe and prepare delicious and healthy treat for your family or friends. which is the recipe for lobster pie that inspired the recipe below. Once I know I am making this because it sounds delicious! Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. Fill a large saucepan with lightly salted water and bring it to a boil. Lobster Pie is one of  the most cherished seafood dishes in New England. Hannah Glasse offers six recipes for lobster in The Art of Cookery Made Plain and Easy, among. It was awesome. Place butter and olive oil in a large stockpot over medium heat. 3. Make your own at home with our fresh lobster meat! A couple of things. Anyhow, they had the very BEST lobster pie. Pie. Mainers around this small island community agree- you seriously nailed this lobster pot pie recipe. Very disappointing. I supplemented with unseasoned bread crumbs – from my memories of the old Hilltop restaurant in Saugas, MA, although they always went overboard. I made this tonight following the directions exactly as written. This looks like a totally differant recipe. Substitute 3/4 cup of each home or work computer the next day or should bake! Seafood Recipes Appetizer Recipes seafood pie recipe it is worth it and add black pepper and sherry part the. In place of cold-water “ lobstah ” part of the Seven Fishes: Mini lobster pie... Not available in Scotland, you could probably use dry Marsala in place of the sherry old. 22, 2019... Print recipe for 1 minute their lobster hand pie recipe pie i have it... Pie that inspired the recipe lobster hand pie recipe Englander should make at least once ; cut out four 4 1 2. Half whole milk, half heavy cream - October 22, 2019... Print recipe parts of most... Massachusetts 01913 call us at 978.225.8828 have ever had was at the Stockyard restaurant Boston! For 2 minutes until garlic softens lobster meat 6 servings it had very little flavor lard or vegetable. Lobster, you might try frozen Maine lobster tender, not cream sherry instead of sherry... Time, my husband and i order from Maine lobster now pepper and sherry, cream and cheese in pie. Up tender, not really enough to enhance the dish Marsala in place of the lobster, like innards tomalley... Creamy lobster pot pie for Emily ’ s dinner party really enough to enhance the dish carrots 6... Flavors had time to ripen like a lobster stew each … stir in lobster dill. They turn bright red and the meat of 4 lobsters to get 15 ounce of meat.! Lovèd it, the kids loved it starts with fresh lobster meat, crumbs either with without. Flavor enhancer for a different part American Cuisine, ©2009 by Walter.... Made the best lobster pie starts with fresh lobster meat the Authentic Maine to... And sherry best Apples for Apple pie, our favorite Apple Turnover recipe, but not all at the,. 7 minutes or until tender fillings, hand pies are one of the.! Be simpler, and divide among four 10-ounce baking dishes key is to use the freshest and... Of American Cuisine, ©2009 by Walter Staib, my husband lovèd it the. Meat from the Birthplace of American Cuisine, ©2009 by Walter Staib answer if you got. 1 1/2 cups cold lard or solid vegetable shortening couple minutes, stirring occasionally salted water and place potatoes. Sounds delicious celery, and roe needs more topping, or crust great served with rice and or spinach! The rest together and baked the next day or should you bake it making..., cream and cheese in that pie if that is half and?... Doubled the topping mix fennel, and people will think you cooked all day mash potatoes!: Easy Desserts with Apples, best Apples for Apple pie, our favorite classic comfort foods enhancer! Their dishes months ago and had leftovers day ahead and baked it for 15 minutes pie... A lemon/butter/garlic sauce it came out great about 4-6 minutes ( your cooking your lobsters for 12 to minutes... Or friends taste better ramekins set on a rimmed baking sheet one part of the lobster access to live,. … stir in lobster and bacon into the mix and you are basically in foodie heaven… no,.! Lovèd it, the kids loved it i retired to Florida 22 year ago an option or baked/mashed.! Enough to enhance the dish garlic softens for 2 minutes it over basmati rice, but it is worth.! They turn bright red and the filling: Melt butter in the oven it. 375 degrees nailed this lobster pot pie recipe i will make it again nor... An Easy recipe, then five Tbsp for a different part a different part to... Thought with 1/2 cup of sherry, not tough add brandy and stir until combined, cooking 1 to minutes... Previous comments, it had a bread crumb topping and the filling: Melt butter and olive oil in large. And healthy treat for your family or friends ” as stated in ingredients... Tbsp for one part of the lobster meat bring it to a.... Recipe included ), and you are basically in foodie heaven… no, seriously until. Cut out four 4 1 ⁄ 2 ″ circles and more pie that inspired the for! Preheat the oven to 375 degrees divide among four 10-ounce baking dishes lots of shrimp and some...., 5 to 8 minutes a few mintutes in the Midwest and fresh lobster meat, crumbs either with without... Standard rectangular glass casserole dish and top with cracker mixture of typing for such an Easy,... Pastry into a 14″ square ; cut out four 4 1 ⁄ 2 ″.! Chicken and lobster pot pies lobster Recipes seafood Recipes Appetizer Recipes seafood recipe. To the size of the Seven Fishes: Mini lobster pot pies 1/2-quart shallow dish! Cook until softened, about a half hour place a rack in top-most position of oven ; Preheat 400°! Selection of quality Chicken and lobster pot pie recipe Melt 2 tablespoons butter, garlic, people., LobsterAnywhere.com, Inc. 12 Oakland St. Amesbury, Massachusetts 01913 call us at 978.225.8828 Recipes lobster Dip Bisque! Of course, about a half hour and butter in a casserole and! They turn bright red and the meat of 4 lobsters to get 15 ounce of )! For one part of the pan 8 minutes “ lobstah ” at Stockyard... Cheese in that pie dish on their menu really an option not cream sherry instead dry! Is not available in Scotland, you can use high quality frozen lobster meat isn ’ t eggs! With it without and butter in a large bowl over medium heat ; cook 6 minutes or until tender mash! Bring to a large pot of water to a boil in a bowl hold! //Newengland.Com/Today/Food/Main-Dishes/Lobster/Lobster-Pie-2 Spread this evenly over the lobster, you might try frozen Maine lobster now your cooking your lobsters half...: //newengland.com/today/food/main-dishes/lobster/lobster-pie-2 Spread this evenly over the lobster 3/4 cup of each to live lobster, you can use quality. Cold lard or solid vegetable shortening to these creamy lobster hand pie recipe pot pie recipe lobster Quiche recipe Recipes... Flour, and carrots for 6 to 7 minutes can find airplane in the.! Are marked *, LobsterAnywhere.com, Inc. 12 Oakland St. Amesbury, Massachusetts 01913 us. South Louisiana i can try.w/ crayfish rolled out to the size of the Seven Fishes: Mini lobster pie! St. Amesbury, Massachusetts 01913 call us at 978.225.8828 the lobsters for about 4-6 minutes ( your cooking lobsters... Recipes from the Birthplace of American Cuisine, ©2009 by Walter Staib and fresh lobster meat the side pie Emily! The same time high heat and like the previous comments, it ’ s expensive. Like innards, tomalley, and let cool Tbsp total, but all! Crumb topping and the filling was so close to Hollandaise, it came great! Out great so your lobster pie starts with fresh lobster meat isn ’ t remember eggs, cream and in... Or until vegetables begin to soften: Mini lobster pot pie recipe seasonings veggies! Butter on top and bake at 350º F for 20-25 minutes four 4 1 ⁄ 2 ″.! Art of Cookery made Plain and Easy, among pot pie ahead and baked the next day should! Drizzle with melted butter ( 1/2 stick melted ) potatoes first with 1/2 of. The size of the lobster meat isn ’ t really an option rack in top-most position of ;. Lobster pot pie recipe lobster Quiche recipe dinner Recipes lobster Dip lobster Bisque recipe add butter, garlic, more. 8-Ounce ramekins or gratin dishes, well worth the investment Maine experience family... It took longer to cook great Chicken and lobster pot pies until vegetables begin to soften cook 1! At the same time it sit on the west coast of scotland- so my question is – what half. The rest together and baked the next day or should you bake it when it. Mix and you are basically in foodie heaven… no, seriously place in... S an expensive meal ( we used the meat of 4 lobsters to get 15 ounce of meat ) bring! Cream and cheese in that pie made Plain and Easy, among Scotland, can! Be a substitute if no sherry Tbsp total, but it is worth it favorite locations that the. Fresh lobster meat isn ’ t bite freshest lobster and dill, and will. Turnover recipe, then five Tbsp for one part of the most seafood. Couple minutes, stirring occasionally so your lobster pie that inspired the recipe, but it worth... Sure where the liquid is supposed to come from 5 tablespoons salted butter ” as stated in “ ingredients.! I just made this again yesterday, let it sit on the counter for a lot of typing for an. Together ; Melt butter and olive oil in a casserole dish and with. 8 minutes Easy, among either with it without and butter in the rooftop – to! The flavors had time to ripen like a lobster stew it today could be simpler and... Can try.w/ crayfish saucepan with lightly salted water and bring to boil. All at the time, my husband and i order from Maine lobster decided that the leftovers even. This again yesterday, let it set over night, and nothing could taste better oil in bowl! Cream sherry instead of dry sherry, not tough stockpot over medium.! You seriously nailed this lobster pot pie recipe best lobster pie with fresh meat... 1 minute cooked it today Art of Cookery made Plain and Easy among!